Bolted Joint Strength vs Published Tests
Six double-shear joints in IM7-8552, three ways to predict them, and why an open-hole d0 does not carry over.
Problem
Camanho and Lambert tested six double-shear joints in IM7-8552 [90/0/±45]3s, three bolted (B, clamped at 2.2 N·m) and three pinned (P), sized to fail in bearing, bearing/shear and net tension1. How close does the Bolted Joint tool's loaded-hole analysis get to the measured bearing strength? Each joint is a single fastener with no bypass, so the tool runs it as one loaded hole with the bearing along +x.
Not to scale. The plan view leaves out the side plates. The bolt bears on the half of the hole toward the free end, peaking along the load.
Inputs
| Material | IM7-8552 carbon/epoxy |
| Layup | [90/0/±45]3s |
| Hole diameter D | 6 to 7 mm |
| Joint | Double shear, one fastener, no bypass |
| Criterion | Max stress, ply by ply |
| d0, defaults | 1.5 mm |
| d0, calibrated on open-hole OHT5 | 4.52 mm |
| Finite-width correction | On |
Ply stiffness and strength are the measured unidirectional values from Camanho and Lambert's Tables 1 and 21. The tool does not model clamping, so a bolted specimen and its pinned twin get the same point stress prediction. There are three sets of predictions:
- Tool defaults: the point stress check out of the box, max stress with d0 = 1.5 mm.
- Open-hole d0, reused: the point stress check with d0 = 4.52 mm, the value calibrated on the open-hole test OHT5 in Open-hole strength vs published tests. Same paper, laminate and ply data, and a similar hole size. No joint test is used to calibrate it. This set checks whether an open-hole d0 carries over to a hole with a fastener bearing on it.
- Characteristic curve: the tool's characteristic curve check with the paper's own point-stress distances rot and roc (Table 16).
Predicted against test
One row per joint, in the same order as the table below, with the test failure mode under each name. The tick is the test, and each marker is one method's prediction. The default markers use the tool's starting d0 of 1.5 mm, the open-hole d0 markers use the d0 set so the open-hole specimen OHT5 matches its test exactly, reused here on every joint, and the characteristic curve markers use the paper's own point-stress distances. None of the six joints is a calibration point, so no marker sits on its tick by construction. The open-hole d0 markers land well right of the test tick, which shows why an open-hole d0 should not be reused on a loaded hole.
Left of the test tick: the prediction is below the test, the safe side.
In words: the default and characteristic curve markers sit just left of the test tick, apart from the narrow net-tension strips. The open-hole d0 markers sit far to the right. 2 joints have no open-hole d0 marker, because that d0 reaches past the strip edge.
Results
Bearing strength σb = P/(D t), in MPa, with t the laminate thickness. The error against the test is in brackets.
| Specimen | Failure mode | D (mm) | w/D | e/D | Test | Tool defaults | Open-hole d0 | Curve |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| DSBFB | Bearing | 7 | 6 | 3 | 695 | 539 (−22.5%) | 1208 (+73.8%) | 645 (−7.2%) |
| DSSFB | Bearing/shear | 6 | 6 | 2 | 702 | 613 (−12.7%) | 967 (+37.8%) | 688 (−2.0%) |
| DSTFB | Tension | 6 | 2 | 4 | 527 | 533 (+1.2%) | – | 520 (−1.2%) |
| DSBFP | Bearing | 7 | 6 | 3 | 706 | 539 (−23.7%) | 1208 (+71.0%) | 610 (−13.6%) |
| DSSFP | Bearing/shear | 6 | 6 | 2 | 699 | 613 (−12.4%) | 967 (+38.3%) | 635 (−9.2%) |
| DSTFP | Tension | 6 | 2 | 4 | 461 | 533 (+15.7%) | – | 520 (+12.9%) |
A dash means the open-hole d0 reaches past the strip edge. Sources: Camanho and Lambert Table 17 (experimental column), geometry Table 15, distances Table 161.
What it means
At the defaults the point stress check comes out 12 to 24 percent below the test for the bearing and bearing/shear specimens, the safe side. For the net-tension specimens, in w/D = 2 strips, it comes out 1 percent above for the bolted one and 16 percent above for the pinned one. The pinned specimen broke 13 percent lower than its bolted twin, and the tool gives both the same prediction because it does not model clamping. In a narrow strip, check net tension against an open-hole tension allowable from tests. The characteristic curve lands 2 to 14 percent below the test on bearing and bearing/shear, 1 percent below on the bolted narrow strip and 13 percent above on the pinned one.
The stress checks are not validated for joints that fail in bearing. Size bearing on the Bearing margin with a tested ASTM D5961 allowable7, and use the point stress check alongside it.
Single-lap, single-bolt tests
We ran the point stress check with the same notch defaults (max stress, d0 = 1.5 mm, finite-width correction on), bearing along +x and the secondary bending of the single lap, against five published single-lap, single-bolt joint tests2: D = 9.53 mm, e = 13.4 mm, widths from 19 to 38 mm, in a [±453/90/±452/04/90/04/±452/90/±453] carbon laminate3. The predicted failure loads came out at 25 to 44 percent of the measured ones, the safe side by a wide margin.
Without the bending they were 24 to 44 percent above, with the governing point a shear mode in a 45° ply at the 0° station, right under the bearing peak. With it, the governing point moves to the bottom of the outer 45° ply at the 75° station, again in shear. The strain concentration K that scales the bending there is about 1.6, and the bending makes up about 84 percent of that ply's shear stress, so how far the bending concentrates at the hole drives this result. That station sits near the net section, where K reads above the shell model.
We also tried a laminate-level check on the stress averaged over d0. It brought these five within 13 percent of the test but put the six IM7-8552 double-shear joints 34 to 43 percent below their tests, so the tool does not use it.
Pull-through tests
Pull-through has its own two checks, and the estimate is Kassapoglou's lower-bound formula6. Catalanotti and co-workers pulled M6 and M10 bolts with washers through glass fabric laminates about 7 mm thick, in phenolic and in vinylester4. With their interlaminar shear strength of 48.8 MPa and a standard washer assumed (the paper does not give its size), the estimate lands at 0.69 to 0.76 of the load at the first load drop in all four configurations. That is the safe side, and close enough to be useful.
Banbury and Kelly pulled three head sizes through one 3.5 mm carbon/epoxy laminate5. If the strength scales with Do as the formula says, each failure load gives back the same Zrθ. The three agree within 7 percent.
Related docs:
- Bolted joints: the loaded hole, the classical margins and load sharing
- Bolted Joint limitations
- The characteristic curve check
References
- Camanho, P.P. & Lambert, M. (2006). A design methodology for mechanically fastened joints in laminated composite materials. Composites Science and Technology, 66(15), 3004-3020. doi:10.1016/j.compscitech.2006.02.017 (Tables 1-2, IM7-8552 ply data; Tables 15-17, double-shear joint tests and characteristic distances)
- Aluko, O. (2011). An analytical method for failure prediction of composite pinned joints. Proceedings of the World Congress on Engineering 2011, London, 6-8 July 2011, pp. 2581-2587. Lecture Notes in Engineering and Computer Science. Paper (PDF)
- Kweon, J.H., Ahn, H.S. & Choi, J.H. (2004). A new method to determine the characteristic lengths of composite joints without testing. Composite Structures, 66(1-4), 305-315. doi:10.1016/j.compstruct.2004.04.053
- Catalanotti, G., Camanho, P.P., Ghys, P. & Marques, A.T. (2011). Experimental and numerical study of fastener pull-through failure in GFRP laminates. Composite Structures, 94, 239-245. (Tables 3-8, pull-through tests)
- Banbury, A. & Kelly, D.W. (1999). A study of fastener pull-through failure of composite laminates. Part 1: Experimental. Composite Structures, 45, 241-254. (Tables 1-2, pull-through tests with three head sizes)
- Kassapoglou, C. (2013). Design and Analysis of Composite Structures, 2nd ed. Wiley. Section 11.2.1.1. (Eq. 11.12, pull-through)
- ASTM D5961/D5961M. Standard Test Method for Bearing Response of Polymer Matrix Composite Laminates. ASTM International.