Open the calculatorOpen the calculator

Why an Unsymmetric Laminate Warps: the B Matrix

Two cross-ply laminates, the same tension. One stretches. The other bends.

Problem

Take a two-ply [0/90] laminate of T300/5208 carbon/epoxy and a four-ply [0/90]s laminate of the same material. Load each with Nx = 100 N/mm of tension and nothing else: no moment, no shear. What are the midplane strains and curvatures, and what shape does a 200 mm square plate take?

1: 0°2: 90°NxNx[0/90]1: 0°2: 90°3: 90°4: 0°NxNx[0/90]sEdge-on, ply 1 on top. Dashed: midplane.

Ply 1 on top, 0.125 mm each. In [0/90] the 0° ply sits above the midplane and the 90° ply below it.

Inputs

Layups[0/90] and [0/90]s, ply 1 on top
Ply thickness0.125 mm
Nx100 N/mm
E1181000 MPa
E210300 MPa
G127170 MPa
ν120.28

See the plate bend

Out-of-plane deflection from the curvatures, measured from the plate center:

w(x,y)=−12(κxx2+κyy2+κxy xy)w(x, y) = -\tfrac{1}{2}\left(\kappa_x x^2 + \kappa_y y^2 + \kappa_{xy}\, x y\right)

Move Nx and the [0/90] edge lifts in proportion. The [0/90]s line stays on zero at every load.

At 100 N/mm the linear answer puts the plate edge 555 mm out of plane, more than the plate is wide. That is far outside the small-deflection range CLT assumes, so read the shape and its sign there, not the size. Slide down to a few N/mm for deflections a real plate would show.

-125-75-2525751250200400600x (mm), along y = 0w (mm)
[0/90][0/90]sDifferent scales on the two axes.

Nx = 100 N/mm

Plan view of the [0/90] plate, darker where |w| is larger. The [0/90]s plate stays flat.

[0/90][0/90]s
εx0 (µε)103602084
κx (1/mm)−0.11090
w at x = ±100 mm554.6 mm0 mm

At Nx = 100 N/mm the [0/90] plate bends into a cylinder about the y axis: its edges at x = ±100 mm sit 554.6 mm off the center. The [0/90]s plate only stretches, by 2084 µε, and stays flat.

Results

[0/90] under Nx = 100 N/mm
Bends
κx = −0.1109 1/mm
[0/90]s under Nx = 100 N/mm
Stays flat
κx = 0 1/mm

The [0/90] laminate has a non-zero B matrix, so pulling on it in x also curves it in x. The [0/90]s laminate has twice the plies, the same ply angles, and B = 0. It only stretches.

Classical Lamination Theory ties the running loads and moments to the midplane strains and curvatures through the ABD matrix:

{NM}=[ABBD]{ε0κ}\begin{Bmatrix} N \\ M \end{Bmatrix} = \begin{bmatrix} A & B \\ B & D \end{bmatrix} \begin{Bmatrix} \varepsilon^0 \\ \kappa \end{Bmatrix}

A in N/mm, B in N and D in N·mm. The B block (shaded) couples stretching and bending. Each row of the table is one equation.

[0/90]

εx0εy0γxy0κxκyκxy
Nx24019.7724.23101339.5700
Ny724.23124019.700−1339.570
Nxy001792.5000
Mx1339.5700125.1023.772040
My0−1339.5703.77204125.1020
Mxy000009.33594

[0/90]s

εx0εy0γxy0κxκyκxy
Nx48039.31448.460000
Ny1448.4648039.30000
Nxy003585000
Mx0001670.630.17630
My00030.1763331.0340
Mxy0000074.6875

The A matrix of [0/90]s is exactly twice that of [0/90], because it has twice as many of the same plies. B is where they part. In [0/90] the stiff 0° ply sits on one side of the midplane and the soft 90° ply on the other, so B11 = 1339.57 N and B22 = −1339.57 N. Mirror the stack and every ply above the midplane has a twin below it at the same angle, so each term of B cancels.

Invert the 6 x 6 matrix and multiply by the load vector (Nx, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0). Strains in µε, curvatures in 1/mm:

Laminateεx0εy0γxy0κxκyκxy
[0/90]10360−312.30−0.110900
[0/90]s2084−62.820000

The [0/90] laminate stretches 4.97 times as much as [0/90]s. Half the thickness accounts for a factor of 2. The rest comes from B: a laminate that is free to bend also gives more in its own plane. And it bends, κx = −0.1109 1/mm, with no moment applied. κy and κxy are zero to rounding, so the plate bends about the y axis only, into a cylinder.

What it means

Along x the 0° ply is about 18 times stiffer than the 90° ply, so the stiffness of [0/90] is centerd in the top ply, above the midplane. Nx acts at the midplane, below that center. The pull is off-center, the soft bottom ply stretches more than the top, and the plate curves with the 90° ply on the convex side. That is B at work: in-plane load in, curvature out. In a symmetric stack the stiffness is centerd on the midplane, so the same pull only stretches it.

This is the linear CLT answer to a mechanical load. A real thin [0/90] plate also curls on its own when it cools from the cure temperature, before any load goes on, because the two plies shrink by different amounts across the fibers. The hygrothermal docs cover that thermal and moisture response.

So if a part has to stay flat under in-plane load, make the layup symmetric. If it cannot be symmetric, check B before you trust a membrane-only answer: the strains and the ply stresses both change once the laminate bends.

Related docs:

References

  1. Jones, R.M., Mechanics of Composite Materials, 2nd Ed., Taylor & Francis, 1999.
  2. Barbero, E.J., Introduction to Composite Materials Design, 3rd Ed., CRC Press, 2017.
Open in calculator

Build the [0/90] stack yourself in the free laminate calculator and watch the B matrix fill in. It opens with its own default layup, so enter the two plies by hand.

Open the laminate calculator
Written by Rick Schrijver
Share