Fifteen IM7-8552 coupons with a hole in the middle. What the point stress check predicts, and what they broke at.
Problem
A carbon/epoxy strip with a central hole is pulled in tension until it breaks. How close does the Whitney-Nuismer point stress check get to the measured failure stress, first at the Open Hole tool's defaults and then with a characteristic distance d0 calibrated on one test? The specimens are 15 published open-hole tension tests in IM7-8552: Camanho and Lambert's nine1, two smaller holes from Camanho et al.2, both in [90/0/±45]3s, and Green et al.'s four [45/90/−45/0]4s specimens, also tabulated by Camanho et al.
Not to scale. The point stress check reads σx at the dot, d0 from the hole edge on the net section.
Inputs
Material
IM7-8552 carbon/epoxy
Layups
[90/0/±45]3s, [45/90/−45/0]4s
Hole diameter D
2 to 25.4 mm
w/D
2 to 6
Criterion
Max stress, ply by ply
d0, defaults
1.5 mm
d0, calibrated on OHT5
4.52 mm
Finite-width correction
On
Ply stiffness and strength are the measured unidirectional values in Camanho and Lambert's Tables 1 and 21. Each specimen is one open hole under uniaxial tension, with Tan's finite-width correction on4. There are two sets of predictions:
Tool defaults: what the tool gives out of the box, max stress with d0 = 1.5 mm.
d0 calibrated on one test: d0 = 4.52 mm, set so the tool matches OHT5 exactly, then used unchanged on every other specimen. This is the calibration the d0 input asks you to do with your own coupons.
Predicted against test
One row per specimen, in the same order as the table below. The tick is the test, and each marker is one method's prediction, so the gap between them is the error. The default markers use the tool's starting d0 of 1.5 mm, and the calibrated markers use a d0 set so OHT5 matches its test exactly, then reused on every other specimen.
Left of the test tick: the prediction is below the test, the safe side.
Each marker is one specimen: its test result across, the prediction up. On the dashed line the two are equal. Below it the prediction is lower than the test, the safe side.
OHT1
OHT2
OHT3
OHT4
OHT5
OHT6
OHT7
OHT8
OHT9
C12-d2
C12-d4
G-3.175
G-6.35
G-12.7
G-25.4
200300400500600
Test and predicted failure stress (MPa)
Test1,2 (safe side to its left)Tool defaultsd0 calibrated on one test
In words: all 15 default markers sit left of the test tick. The calibrated markers sit on or near it, with the 2 mm and 25.4 mm holes furthest left. 2 specimens have no calibrated marker, because the calibrated d0 reaches past the strip edge.
Calibrate d0 yourself
Move the slider to change d0. Every specimen's marker moves with it. To calibrate, pick one specimen and slide until its marker sits on its test tick. Then look at where the other specimens land. A larger d0 reads the stress further from the hole, where it is lower, so the predicted strength goes up.
d0 = 1.5 mm
10
1 of 15 within 12% of the test, 15 on the safe side.
Left of the test tick: the prediction is below the test, the safe side.
Each marker is one specimen: its test result across, the prediction up. On the dashed line the two are equal. Below it the prediction is lower than the test, the safe side.
The slider moves in 0.1 mm steps, so the calibrated stop is 4.5 mm rather than the exact 4.52 mm.
Results
Tool defaults, d0 = 1.5 mm
10 to 40% below test
15 of 15 on the safe side
d0 calibrated on one test, 4.52 mm
11 of 13 within 12%
18% low to 3% high
Remote gross failure stress, load over width times thickness, in MPa.
Specimen
Layup
D (mm)
w/D
Test
Tool defaults
Error
Calibrated d0
Error
OHT1
[90/0/±45]3s
6
2
252
227
−10.0%
–
–
OHT2
[90/0/±45]3s
6
4
373
298
−20.1%
385
+3.3%
OHT3
[90/0/±45]3s
6
6
439
311
−29.1%
402
−8.4%
OHT4
[90/0/±45]3s
8
2
247
204
−17.5%
–
–
OHT5
[90/0/±45]3s
8
4
367
269
−26.6%
367
+0.1%
OHT6
[90/0/±45]3s
8
6
376
281
−25.2%
383
+1.9%
OHT7
[90/0/±45]3s
10
2
261
189
−27.5%
267
+2.4%
OHT8
[90/0/±45]3s
10
4
345
249
−27.7%
351
+1.9%
OHT9
[90/0/±45]3s
10
6
374
260
−30.4%
366
−2.1%
C12-d2
[90/0/±45]3s
2
6
556
401
−27.8%
456
−17.9%
C12-d4
[90/0/±45]3s
4
6
481
352
−26.8%
427
−11.2%
G-3.175
[45/90/−45/0]4s
3.175
5
478
364
−23.8%
432
−9.6%
G-6.35
[45/90/−45/0]4s
6.35
5
433
301
−30.5%
392
−9.5%
G-12.7
[45/90/−45/0]4s
12.7
5
374
237
−36.6%
342
−8.6%
G-25.4
[45/90/−45/0]4s
25.4
5
331
198
−40.2%
272
−17.8%
A dash means the calibrated d0 reaches past the strip edge, which the tool blocks. Sources: OHT1-OHT9, Camanho and Lambert Table 6 (geometry Table 5)1. C12-d2 and C12-d4, Camanho et al. Table 2. G-3.175 to G-25.4, Camanho et al. Table 32.
What it means
On this material the default d0 of 1.5 mm is conservative. Every prediction falls below the test, by 10 to 40 percent. The narrow w/D = 2 strips are no exception, which is Tan's factor at work4: it raises the field beside the hole by 42% at w/D = 2.
Calibrating d0 on one specimen brings the w/D = 4 to 6 rows within 12%, except the 2 mm hole and the 25.4 mm hole, which come out 18% low. One d0 does not carry across a 12 to 1 range of hole size. That is the hole size effect, and the point stress criterion only approximates it3. Fit d0 on coupons with a hole close to the size you are sizing, run to ASTM D57665.
The conservative default is a property of this material, not of the method. On Tan's AS4/3502 coupons the same default reads high. See Elliptical cut-outs vs published tests.
Camanho, P.P. & Lambert, M. (2006). A design methodology for mechanically fastened joints in laminated composite materials. Composites Science and Technology, 66(15), 3004-3020. doi:10.1016/j.compscitech.2006.02.017 (Tables 1-2, IM7-8552 ply data; Tables 5-6, open-hole tension tests)
Camanho, P.P., Erçin, G.H., Catalanotti, G., Mahdi, S. & Linde, P. (2012). A finite fracture mechanics model for the prediction of the open-hole strength of composite laminates. Composites Part A, 43(8), 1219-1225. doi:10.1016/j.compositesa.2012.03.004 (Table 2, IM7-8552 open-hole tests; Table 3, Green et al.'s tests)
Tan, S.C. (1988). Finite-width correction factors for anisotropic plate containing a central opening. Journal of Composite Materials, 22(11), 1080-1097. doi:10.1177/002199838802201105
ASTM D5766/D5766M. Standard Test Method for Open-Hole Tensile Strength of Polymer Matrix Composite Laminates. ASTM International.
Open the Open Hole tool
Model one of these coupons with your own ply data and adjust d0 until it matches your test. The method is on Open-Hole Strength.