Ply Stresses in a ±55° Composite Pressure Tube
A closed-end tube under internal pressure carries twice as much load around the hoop as along the axis. See how a ±55° winding shares that load, and what an unsymmetric wall does with it.
Problem
A thin-walled composite tube with closed ends holds an internal pressure pi = 1 MPa on a mean radius r̄ = 50 mm. The wall is four E-glass/epoxy plies wound at [55/−55/−55/55]. Find the stresses in each ply along and across its fibers, and the Tsai-Wu safety factor. Then swap the wall for an unsymmetric [0/45/90] carbon/epoxy layup and see what the tube has to carry to keep it round.
Not to scale. Fibers wind at +55° (solid) and −55° (dashed) to the tube axis x. The wall element carries Nx along the axis and Ny around the hoop.
Inputs
| ±55° vessel | Unsymmetric tube | |
|---|---|---|
| Material | E-glass/epoxy | T300/5208 carbon/epoxy |
| Layup | [55/−55/−55/55] | [0/45/90], 0° ply inside |
| Ply thickness (mm) | 0.125 | 0.125 |
| Wall thickness t (mm) | 0.5 | 0.375 |
| E1 (MPa) | 41000 | 181000 |
| E2 (MPa) | 10400 | 10300 |
| G12 (MPa) | 4300 | 7170 |
| ν12 | 0.28 | 0.28 |
| S1t / S1c (MPa) | 1100 / 620 | not used |
| S2t / S2c (MPa) | 35 / 141 | not used |
| S12 (MPa) | 63 | not used |
| Mean radius r̄ (mm) | 50 | |
| Internal pressure pi (MPa) | 1 | |
| Ends | Closed | |
Cutting the tube across its axis and along its length gives the resultants on the mean radius2. With closed ends Nx = pir̄/2 = 25 N/mm and Ny = pir̄ = 50 N/mm, with Nxy = 0. Statics alone fixes that 2:1 ratio, so both tubes see the same N.
Why 55°
Same material, same N, any winding angle from 0 to 90°. The curves show the +θ ply; the −θ ply has the same σ1 and σ2 and the opposite τ12.
[55/−55]s under Nx = 25 N/mm, Ny = 50 N/mm
| Ply | σ1 | σ2 | τ12 | SF |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| +55° | 121 | 28.7 | 9.77 | 1.35 |
| −55° | 121 | 28.7 | −9.77 | 1.35 |
Stresses in MPa, in the fiber axes of each ply.
At θ = 55° the +θ ply carries σ1 = 121, σ2 = 28.7 and τ12 = 9.77 MPa. Tsai-Wu gives a safety factor of 1.35.
σ1 + σ2 stays at 150.0 MPa at every angle, which is (Nx + Ny)/t. The angle only decides how that stress splits between the fibers and the matrix, and how much shear comes with it.
Results
The ±55° vessel
The layup is symmetric and balanced, so the zero-curvature solve gives the ordinary laminate result1. Every ply carries the same stresses apart from the sign of the shear. In MPa:
| Stress | Axes | +55° plies | −55° plies |
|---|---|---|---|
| σx | Tube | 50.0 | 50.0 |
| σy | Tube | 100.0 | 100.0 |
| τxy | Tube | 40.1 | −40.1 |
| σ1 | Ply | 121.3 | 121.3 |
| σ2 | Ply | 28.7 | 28.7 |
| τ12 | Ply | 9.8 | −9.8 |
| Tsai-Wu SF | 1.35 | 1.35 |
Every ply sits at the same angle to the hoop, so σx and σy come out at the average wall stress N/t. The shear stresses of the +55° and −55° plies cancel, which is how Nxy stays zero. In the ply axes the picture is clearer: the fibers carry 121.3 MPa, more than four times the 28.7 MPa across them, and the in-plane shear is 9.8 MPa.
The unsymmetric [0/45/90] tube
Now three T300/5208 plies, the 0° ply on the inner surface, the 45° ply in the middle and the 90° ply outermost. A flat laminate like this curls under in-plane load, because B ≠ 0. A closed tube cannot curl its wall, so the solve holds the curvature at zero and the wall carries the moment M = Bε0 as a reaction1:
| Quantity | x | y | xy |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mid-surface strain ε0 (µε) | 769.7 | 1766 | −1784 |
| Reaction moment M (N·mm/mm) | −2.062 | 4.732 | 0.000 |
To stay round and straight, the wall carries a hoop bending moment My of 4.732 N·mm/mm and an axial one, Mx, of −2.062 N·mm/mm. A flat [0/45/90] plate under the same N would take that as curvature instead. The shear strain is not zero either. The single 45° ply leaves the layup unbalanced, so the tube twists under pressure alone, at dφ/dx = γ0xy/r̄ = −3.57 × 10−5 rad/mm.
What it means
The slider shows where 55° comes from. At 0° the fibers run along the axis and the hoop stress, the larger of the two, lands across them: σ2 = 100.0 MPa and a Tsai-Wu safety factor of 0.356. At 90° the fibers take the hoop load and the axial half still goes into the matrix, σ2 = 50.0 MPa, so the factor only reaches 0.752.
In between, σ2 drops to its lowest value, 28.6 MPa at 53°, and the safety factor peaks at 1.35 at 55°. The shear does not vanish there. τ12 changes sign near 65°, and at 55° it is still 9.8 MPa. Because σ1 + σ2 is fixed, the lowest σ2 is also the highest σ1: near 55° the wall puts the most of the 2:1 load along the fibers and the least across them, where E-glass/epoxy is weakest.
The unsymmetric tube is a different lesson. Its strains are the same at every height in the wall, and the moments it needs to stay round are reactions, not loads anyone applies. Run the same layup as a flat plate and you get curvature and a different set of ply stresses.
Related docs:
- Statics: from loads to force resultants
- Why the wall is solved with zero curvature
- The moments are reactions, not loads
- Tsai-Wu failure criterion
References
- Jones, R.M. (1999). Mechanics of Composite Materials, 2nd ed. Taylor & Francis. Chapter 4. ISBN: 978-1560327127. (Eq. 4.13 for the strain through the thickness, Eq. 4.22-4.24 for the laminate stiffnesses)
- NASA Langley Research Center. (2020). Buckling of Thin-Walled Circular Cylinders. NASA/SP-8007-2020/REV 2. (Section 4.1.1, Eq. 17-18 for the pressure membrane stresses) ntrs.nasa.gov