• Docs
  • Laminate Analysis
Open the toolOpen the tool

Cuntze Failure Criterion

The Cuntze Failure Mode Concept for a composite ply: five mode efforts, the interaction exponent, the friction term, and one ply worked by hand.

What the Cuntze criterion predicts

The Cuntze Failure Mode Concept (FMC) starts from one rule: one failure mode is one physical mechanism, governed by one basic strength1. A unidirectional ply has five strengths, so it gets five failure conditions. Two are fiber modes, FF1 in tension and FF2 in compression. Three are inter-fiber modes: IFF1 in transverse tension, IFF2 in shear and IFF3 in transverse compression.

Each mode gives a stressing effort, the share of that mode's capacity in use. The efforts are then combined in a separate, explicit step. Puck builds the interaction into the fracture condition. Cuntze adds it afterwards, so the governing mode is a direct output.

Cuntze belongs to the failure-mode family. The cards draw each family's failure envelope for the same ply in the σ1-σ2 plane, with no shear. Cuntze runs in the dashboard only, so its card names it without a curve.

σ1σ2
No interaction
Max stressMax strain

Each stress, or each strain, is checked against its own limit. Max stress draws a box with sharp corners. Max strain draws a slanted box, because the Poisson effect puts some σ1 into ε2.

σ1σ2
Quadratic interaction
Tsai-HillTsai-Wu

All stresses go into one quadratic expression. The envelope is one smooth, ellipse-like curve, and it does not say whether the fiber or the matrix failed.

σ1σ2
Failure modes
HashinPuck

Fiber and matrix failure get separate checks. The envelope is pieced together from one curve or line per mode.

Also in this family, not drawn: Cuntze, Sun, Edge.

When to use Cuntze

Use it when you want the failure mode and a mode-by-mode breakdown of the load, with fewer parameters than Puck. Alongside Puck it is one of the two criteria VDI 2014 Part 3 recommends2. For a quick check under combined loading, Tsai-Wu needs no extra parameters.

Cuntze formula

In plane stress the five mode efforts are1:

FF1 (σ1≥0):  σ1S1t\text{FF1 } (\sigma_1 \ge 0): \; \frac{\sigma_1}{S_{1t}}
FF2 (σ1<0):  −σ1S1c\text{FF2 } (\sigma_1 < 0): \; \frac{-\sigma_1}{S_{1c}}
IFF1 (σ2≥0):  σ2S2t\text{IFF1 } (\sigma_2 \ge 0): \; \frac{\sigma_2}{S_{2t}}
IFF3 (σ2<0):  −σ2S2c\text{IFF3 } (\sigma_2 < 0): \; \frac{-\sigma_2}{S_{2c}}
IFF2 (shear):  ∣τ12∣+B⊥∥min⁡(σ2, 0)S12\text{IFF2 (shear)}: \; \frac{|\tau_{12}| + B_{\perp\parallel}\min(\sigma_2,\, 0)}{S_{12}}

and they combine as

Effm˙=∑modes(Effmode)m˙\text{Eff}^{\dot m} = \sum_{\text{modes}} \left(\text{Eff}^{\text{mode}}\right)^{\dot m}
failure when Eff≥1\text{failure when Eff} \ge 1

B⊥∥ is a friction parameter and ṁ the interaction exponent. The dashboard uses B⊥∥ = 0.6 and ṁ = 2.5, representative values for UD plies from Cuntze's own fits. The friction term works like Mohr-Coulomb friction: transverse compression presses the potential fracture plane together and raises the shear the ply can carry. The min(σ2, 0) bracket credits it under compression only, so transverse tension never counts as shear.

Cuntze gives two forms of the shear mode1. In the linear form above, friction lowers the acting stress. In the nonlinear form, it raises the shear allowable. The two agree on each mode's own failure surface. The dashboard uses the linear form because it keeps the safety factor an exact load multiplier. Under combined transverse stress and shear, the linear form reports higher safety factors than the nonlinear one.

Failure index and safety factor

Every mode effort is linear in the stresses, and the ṁ-norm of linear terms is linear too. So the combined effort scales with the load, and the safety factor is SF = 1/Eff. The governing mode is the one with the largest effort. The overview covers safety factors and margins for all criteria.

Worked example: one ply

Take the +45° ply of the quasi-isotropic laminate example. It is T300/5208 carbon/epoxy, with S1c = 1500 MPa, S2c = 246 MPa and S12 = 68 MPa. Its stresses are σ1 = −93.31 MPa, σ2 = −6.69 MPa and τ12 = −40.01 MPa. Both normal stresses are compressive, so FF2, IFF2 and IFF3 are active and FF1 and IFF1 are zero.

FF2, −σ1/S1c0.06221
IFF2, (|τ12| + B⊥∥σ2)/S120.5294
IFF3, −σ2/S2c0.0272
Combined effort Eff0.5305

IFF2 governs, and friction takes 4.014 MPa off the acting shear. The other two efforts are small, and raising them to the power 2.5 shrinks them further, so Eff is only a little above the IFF2 effort. SF = 1/Eff = 1.885, higher than the Puck result for the same ply because B⊥∥ = 0.6 gives more friction credit.

Limitations

  • B⊥∥ and ṁ are curve fits that depend on the material. The defaults are representative values, not measured properties of your ply.
  • The ṁ-norm always lifts Eff above the largest single effort, so the criterion is slightly more conservative than its governing mode alone.
  • It predicts first-ply failure only. What the laminate carries after that is a progressive failure question.

Beyond the Live Calculator

The free calculator does not run Cuntze. The app runs it with eight other criteria on every ply of a laminate, with first ply failure and progressive failure.

Create free account
app.abdcomposites.com
CLIP loops

Frequently asked questions

A failure criterion that gives each of the five ply strengths its own failure mode, FF1, FF2, IFF1, IFF2 and IFF3, and then combines the mode efforts with an interaction exponent.

References

  1. Cuntze, R.G., "Efficient 3D and 2D Failure Conditions for UD Laminae and their Application within the Verification of the Laminate Design", Composites Science and Technology, Vol. 66, 2006, pp. 1081-1096. doi:10.1016/j.compscitech.2004.12.046
  2. VDI 2014 Part 3, "Development of Fibre-Reinforced Plastics Components - Analysis", Verein Deutscher Ingenieure, 2006.
Written by Rick Schrijver
Share