Tsai-Hill Failure Criterion
The Tsai-Hill failure index for a composite ply: the formula, how the strengths are picked, the safety factor, and one ply worked by hand.
What the Tsai-Hill criterion predicts
Tsai-Hill is a quadratic interaction criterion adapted from Hill's yield criterion for anisotropic metals1. It combines σ1, σ2 and τ12 into one failure index, and the ply fails when that index reaches 1. Every stress counts toward failure at once, so a ply that passes a maximum stress check on each component can still fail Tsai-Hill.
It assumes a homogeneous orthotropic ply in plane stress, loaded linearly to failure. Like Tsai-Wu, it gives an index and not a failure mode.
Tsai-Hill belongs to the quadratic interaction family. The cards draw each family's failure envelope for the same ply in the σ1-σ2 plane, with no shear.
Each stress, or each strain, is checked against its own limit. Max stress draws a box with sharp corners. Max strain draws a slanted box, because the Poisson effect puts some σ1 into ε2.
All stresses go into one quadratic expression. The envelope is one smooth, ellipse-like curve, and it does not say whether the fiber or the matrix failed.
Fiber and matrix failure get separate checks. The envelope is pieced together from one curve or line per mode.
Also in this family, not drawn: Cuntze, Sun, Edge.
When to use Tsai-Hill
Use it as a quick interaction check when the tensile and compressive strengths are close, or to compare with older analyses and textbook examples that use it. When they differ, as they do across the fibers in almost every polymer composite, prefer Tsai-Wu. For the failure mode, use Hashin. For the simplest check, each stress against its own strength, see max stress.
Tsai-Hill formula
Failure when FI ≥ 1.0
The formula has no linear terms, so the strengths are picked by sign. S1 is S1t when σ1 is tensile and S1c when it is compressive. S2 is S2t or S2c by the sign of σ2 in the same way. S12 is the in-plane shear strength. The cross term −σ1σ2/S12 is fixed: there is no coefficient to tune.
Failure index and safety factor
Every term is quadratic in stress, so doubling the load multiplies FI by four. The safety factor follows directly:
An FI of 0.25 means the load can double before the ply fails. The overview covers safety factors and margins for all criteria.
Worked example: one ply
Take the +45° ply of the quasi-isotropic laminate example, T300/5208 carbon/epoxy. Its stresses are σ1 = −93.31 MPa, σ2 = −6.69 MPa and τ12 = −40.01 MPa. Both normal stresses are compressive, so S1 = S1c = 1500 MPa and S2 = S2c = 246 MPa, with S12 = 68 MPa.
| (σ1/S1)2 | 0.00387 |
| −σ1σ2/S12 | −0.0002774 |
| (σ2/S2)2 | 0.0007396 |
| (τ12/S12)2 | 0.3462 |
The shear term is almost the whole index. The small transverse compression barely counts, because it is measured against the large compressive strength. FI = 0.3505 and SF = 1/√FI = 1.689. Tsai-Wu gives this ply a higher safety factor, and the worked example shows why.
The classic check of Tsai-Hill is a unidirectional ply pulled in tension at an angle to its fibers. The off-axis strength example repeats that comparison from 0 to 90°.
Limitations
- No linear terms. Picking the strength by sign is a workaround, and the index can be non-conservative under some biaxial stress states when tension and compression strengths differ a lot.
- The interaction term is fixed. You cannot fit it to biaxial test data the way you can fit F12 in Tsai-Wu.
- One index, no failure mode.
- It predicts first-ply failure only. Damage after that is covered on progressive failure.
Frequently asked questions
References
- Jones, R.M., Mechanics of Composite Materials, 2nd Ed., Taylor & Francis, 1999.