• Docs
  • Laminate Analysis
Open the toolOpen the tool

Puck Failure Criterion

The Puck criterion for a composite ply: fiber failure, inter-fiber failure modes A, B and C, the inclination parameters, and one ply worked by hand.

Try it live: Failure Criteria Calculator
Opens with the +45° ply from the worked example below. Change a stress and the Puck mode and index update.
Open live calculator →

What the Puck criterion predicts

Puck splits ply failure into fiber failure (FF) and inter-fiber failure (IFF)1. Fiber failure is a stress check along the fibers. Inter-fiber failure is a fracture of the matrix, or of the fiber-matrix interface, on a plane parallel to the fibers, and Puck treats it with Mohr-Coulomb reasoning: the stresses acting on that plane decide whether it breaks.

That gives three IFF modes. Mode A is transverse tension with shear. Mode B is moderate transverse compression with shear, where compression closes the crack plane and raises the shear the ply can carry. Mode C is dominant transverse compression, where the fracture plane tilts and the ply breaks as a wedge. Puck is the only common criterion that predicts the angle of the fracture plane.

Puck belongs to the failure-mode family. The cards draw each family's failure envelope for the same ply in the σ1-σ2 plane, with no shear.

σ1σ2
No interaction
Max stressMax strain

Each stress, or each strain, is checked against its own limit. Max stress draws a box with sharp corners. Max strain draws a slanted box, because the Poisson effect puts some σ1 into ε2.

σ1σ2
Quadratic interaction
Tsai-HillTsai-Wu

All stresses go into one quadratic expression. The envelope is one smooth, ellipse-like curve, and it does not say whether the fiber or the matrix failed.

σ1σ2
Failure modes
HashinPuck

Fiber and matrix failure get separate checks. The envelope is pieced together from one curve or line per mode.

Also in this family, not drawn: Cuntze, Sun, Edge.

When to use Puck

Use it when the failure mode matters and the matrix is in transverse compression, which is where simpler criteria are least accurate. Mode C also warns of the wedge fracture that can start a delamination. VDI 2014 Part 3 recommends Puck for FRP component analysis3. For a quick check with fewer inputs, Tsai-Wu is the usual choice. If you want mode-based results with a simpler compression treatment, see Sun.

Puck formula

In plane stress the fiber and inter-fiber conditions are1:

Fiber failure:

FF tension: σ1S1t≥1\text{FF tension: } \frac{\sigma_1}{S_{1t}} \ge 1
FF compression: −σ1S1c≥1\text{FF compression: } \frac{-\sigma_1}{S_{1c}} \ge 1

Inter-fiber failure:

Mode A (σ2≥0):  (τ12S12)2+(1−p⊥∥(+)S2tS12)2(σ2S2t)2+p⊥∥(+)σ2S12=1\text{Mode A } (\sigma_2 \ge 0): \; \sqrt{\left(\frac{\tau_{12}}{S_{12}}\right)^2 + \left(1 - p_{\perp\parallel}^{(+)}\frac{S_{2t}}{S_{12}}\right)^2\left(\frac{\sigma_2}{S_{2t}}\right)^2} + p_{\perp\parallel}^{(+)}\frac{\sigma_2}{S_{12}} = 1
Mode B (σ2<0,shear-dominated):\text{Mode B } (\sigma_2 < 0, \text{shear-dominated}):
1S12(τ122+(p⊥∥(−)σ2)2+p⊥∥(−)σ2)=1\frac{1}{S_{12}}\left(\sqrt{\tau_{12}^2 + (p_{\perp\parallel}^{(-)}\sigma_2)^2} + p_{\perp\parallel}^{(-)}\sigma_2\right) = 1
Mode C (σ2<0,compression-dominated):\text{Mode C } (\sigma_2 < 0, \text{compression-dominated}):
[(τ122(1+p⊥⊥(−))S12)2+(σ2S2c)2]−S2cσ2=1\left[\left(\frac{\tau_{12}}{2(1+p_{\perp\perp}^{(-)})S_{12}}\right)^2 + \left(\frac{\sigma_2}{S_{2c}}\right)^2\right]\frac{-S_{2c}}{\sigma_2} = 1

The inclination parameters p⊥∥(+) and p⊥∥(−) set the slope of the fracture envelope where it meets the shear axis. The calculator and the dashboard use 0.25 for both when no test data is given. Puck, Kopp and Knops list typical values of 0.30 and 0.25 for glass/epoxy and 0.35 and 0.30 for carbon/epoxy2. p⊥⊥(−) is not an input. It follows from p⊥∥(−), S2c and S12, and so does the boundary between modes B and C, where both modes give the same result1.

A high fiber stress also weakens the matrix, because single fibers break before the ply fails as a whole. Following VDI 2014 Part 3, Annex A1.23, the effort of modes A, B and C is divided by a weakening factor ηw1. It stays 1 while |σ1| at inter-fiber failure is below half the fiber strength, then falls along an ellipse to 0.5 at the fiber failure limit (s = m = 0.5). The fiber failure check itself is not weakened.

Failure index and safety factor

Each mode's effort is linear in the load: scale every stress by R and the effort scales by R. ηw1 depends only on the ratio of the fiber and inter-fiber efforts, so it does not change that. The failure index is the larger of the FF and IFF efforts, and the safety factor is SF = 1/FI. The overview covers safety factors and margins for all criteria.

Worked example: one ply

Take the +45° ply of the quasi-isotropic laminate example. It is T300/5208 carbon/epoxy, with S1c = 1500 MPa, S2c = 246 MPa and S12 = 68 MPa, and p⊥∥(−) = 0.25. Its stresses are σ1 = −93.31 MPa, σ2 = −6.69 MPa and τ12 = −40.01 MPa. σ2 is small and compressive next to a large shear, so the ply is in mode B.

√(τ122 + (p⊥∥(−)σ2)2), MPa40.05
p⊥∥(−)σ2, MPa−1.673
IFF mode B effort, divided by S120.5643
FF compression effort, −σ1/S1c0.06221

The compression term is negative: squeezing the crack plane shut lets the ply carry more shear. |σ1| is far below half the fiber strength, so ηw1 = 1. Inter-fiber failure governs with FI = 0.5643, and SF = 1/FI = 1.772. That is about 4% above the maximum stress answer of 1.7, which gives no credit for the compression.

Limitations

  • The inclination parameters ideally come from biaxial tests. The default of 0.25 sits at the low end of the typical values2.
  • More inputs and more machinery than an interactive criterion, for a gain that is largest under transverse compression.
  • It predicts first-ply failure only. What the laminate carries after that is a progressive failure question.

Frequently asked questions

Fiber failure is the fibers breaking or kinking, checked against S1t or S1c. Inter-fiber failure is a crack through the matrix on a plane parallel to the fibers, in mode A, B or C depending on σ2 and τ12.

References

  1. Puck, A. & Schurmann, H., "Failure Analysis of FRP Laminates by Means of Physically Based Phenomenological Models", Composites Science and Technology, Vol. 58, 1998, pp. 1045-1067. doi:10.1016/S0266-3538(96)00140-6
  2. Puck, A., Kopp, J. & Knops, M., "Guidelines for the Determination of the Parameters in Puck's Action Plane Strength Criterion", Composites Science and Technology, Vol. 62, 2002, pp. 371-378. doi:10.1016/S0266-3538(01)00202-0
  3. VDI 2014 Part 3, "Development of Fibre-Reinforced Plastics Components - Analysis", Verein Deutscher Ingenieure, 2006.
Written by Rick Schrijver
Share