• Docs
  • Laminate Analysis
Open the toolOpen the tool

Sun Failure Criterion

The Sun criterion for a composite ply: four failure modes, the friction term that lets transverse compression raise the shear strength, and how the safety factor is found.

What the Sun criterion predicts

Sun's criterion fixes one well-documented gap1. Moderate transverse compression raises the apparent in-plane shear strength of a ply, because squeezing the potential fracture plane together makes it harder to slide. Elliptical criteria such as Hashin predict the opposite.

So Sun keeps four separate modes, fiber and matrix in tension and in compression, and changes only matrix compression. There a friction term grows the shear allowable as the compression gets deeper. Each prediction names its mode.

Sun belongs to the failure-mode family. The cards draw each family's failure envelope for the same ply in the σ1-σ2 plane, with no shear. Sun runs in the dashboard only, so its card names it without a curve.

σ1σ2
No interaction
Max stressMax strain

Each stress, or each strain, is checked against its own limit. Max stress draws a box with sharp corners. Max strain draws a slanted box, because the Poisson effect puts some σ1 into ε2.

σ1σ2
Quadratic interaction
Tsai-HillTsai-Wu

All stresses go into one quadratic expression. The envelope is one smooth, ellipse-like curve, and it does not say whether the fiber or the matrix failed.

σ1σ2
Failure modes
HashinPuck

Fiber and matrix failure get separate checks. The envelope is pieced together from one curve or line per mode.

Also in this family, not drawn: Cuntze, Sun, Edge.

When to use Sun

Use it when plies carry shear with transverse compression and you want the failure mode, but not the fracture-plane machinery of Puck. One friction denominator captures the shear strengthening, and it has no free parameter to calibrate. When you need the fracture plane angle, or a compression treatment derived from the mechanism, use Puck.

Sun formula

The ply fails in the first mode that reaches 11:

Fiber tension (σ1≥0):  σ1S1t≥1\text{Fiber tension } (\sigma_1 \ge 0): \; \frac{\sigma_1}{S_{1t}} \ge 1
Fiber compression (σ1<0):  −σ1S1c≥1\text{Fiber compression } (\sigma_1 < 0): \; \frac{-\sigma_1}{S_{1c}} \ge 1
Matrix tension (σ2≥0):\text{Matrix tension } (\sigma_2 \ge 0):
(σ2S2t)2+(τ12S12)2≥1\left(\frac{\sigma_2}{S_{2t}}\right)^2 + \left(\frac{\tau_{12}}{S_{12}}\right)^2 \ge 1
Matrix compression (σ2<0):\text{Matrix compression } (\sigma_2 < 0):
(σ2S2c)2+(τ12S12−ηL σ2)2≥1\left(\frac{\sigma_2}{S_{2c}}\right)^2 + \left(\frac{\tau_{12}}{S_{12} - \eta_L\,\sigma_2}\right)^2 \ge 1

ηL is the friction coefficient. It follows from the fracture plane angle measured in plain transverse compression tests, 53° for both carbon and glass epoxies, which gives ηL = 0.7611 S12/S2c. With σ2 negative, the denominator S12 − ηLσ2 is larger than S12, so the ply carries more shear.

Failure index and safety factor

The fiber modes are linear in the load, so their safety factor is 1/FI. Matrix tension is quadratic, so its safety factor is 1/√FI. Matrix compression is different: scaling the load also scales σ2 in the shear allowable, so no closed form gives the failure load. The dashboard solves it numerically and picks the governing mode by the lowest safety factor, so the reported mode always matches the reported margin. The overview covers safety factors and margins for all criteria.

Worked example

Every worked number on these criterion pages is checked against an independent implementation. The one available runs a different criterion under the Sun name, without the friction term, so this page shows no worked ply. The dashboard runs Sun on every ply of a laminate.

Limitations

  • Phenomenological rather than mechanism-based. For fracture plane prediction or a physically derived compression treatment, use Puck.
  • The 53° fracture angle is a fixed assumption. A ply whose measured angle differs gets a friction coefficient that does not match it.
  • It predicts first-ply failure only. What the laminate carries after that is a progressive failure question.

Beyond the Live Calculator

The free calculator does not run Sun. The app runs it with eight other criteria on every ply of a laminate, with first ply failure and progressive failure.

Create free account
app.abdcomposites.com
CLIP loops

Frequently asked questions

A mode-based ply criterion with fiber and matrix modes in tension and compression. In matrix compression a friction term raises the shear allowable, so moderate transverse compression lets the ply carry more shear.

References

  1. Sun, C.T., Quinn, B.J. & Oplinger, D.W., Comparative Evaluation of Failure Analysis Methods for Composite Laminates, DOT/FAA/AR-95/109, 1996. Equations as given in Davila, C.G., Camanho, P.P. & Rose, C.A., "Failure Criteria for FRP Laminates", NASA/TM-2005-213530, 2005.
Written by Rick Schrijver
Share